Center for Independent Experts Review of the November 2010 Biological Opinion on BSAI and GOA Groundfish Fisheries

Background

NOAA Fisheries contracted with the Center for Independent Experts  to conduct a peer review of the November 2010 Biological Opinion on the Alaska groundfish fisheries, which NOAA Fisheries prepared under Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act (ESA). The CIE is a group that provides independent peer reviews of the science upon which many of NOAA Fisheries' management decisions are based, including reviews of stock assessments for fish and marine mammals. The structure and operation of the CIE are designed to ensure the quality, relevance, and independence of the reviews. Independence is maintained by eliminating any role for NOAA Fisheries in selecting reviewers or in approving the content of reviewers' reports. Reviewers must adhere to a strict conflict of interest policy.

The ESA requires each federal agency to insure than any action authorized, funded, or carried out by the agency is not likely to jeopardize the continued existence of any threatened or endangered species or adversely modify critical habitat. Action agencies must consult with NOAA Fisheries or the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service regarding any action that may affect listed species. For fisheries managed under the Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act, NOAA Fisheries is the action agency and must complete the consultation internally, involving its Sustainable Fisheries Division (responsible for authorization of the fisheries) and Protected Resources Division (responsible for implementing the ESA).
Review Process

The subject of this review is the scientific information and analysis contained in the Biological Opinion. The review consists of two parts: (1) a desk review of the Biological Opinion including information available to NOAA Fisheries through September 3, 2010, and (2) a panel review of new information that became available subsequent to issuance of the Biological Opinion. The Scope of Work and Terms of Reference (TOR) for the CIE review are available.

CIE Reviewers

Dr. Don Bowen
Population Ecology Division
Bedford Institute of Oceanography
Department of Fisheries and Oceans
Dartmouth, Nova Scotia

Dr. Brent Stewart
Senior Research Scientist
Hubbs-Sea World Research Institute
San Diego, California

Dr. Kevin Stokes
Wellington, New Zealand
 

CIE Peer Reviews of the Biological Opinion

• W.D. Bowen, Ph.D.
• Brent S. Stewart, Ph.D., J.D.
• Kevin Stokes, Ph.D.

CIE Review Meeting

August 1–2, 2012: Seattle, WA

• Meeting Notice.
• Agenda.
• Meeting attendees.

Presentations

• D. Fluharty, Introduction and Purpose of CIE Meeting.
• D. Bernard, State of Washington, Department of Fish and Wildlife and State of Alaska, Department of Fish and Game.
• T. Loomis, Fishing Industry Panel.
• M. Horning, Oregon State University and Alaska SeaLife Center.
• V. Burkanov, Marine Mammal Protection Zones in Russia.
• S. MacLean, North Pacific Fishery Management Council.
• J. Warrenchuk, Oceana.
• S. Lowe, AFSC Update on Pacific cod, pollock, and Atka mackerel fisheries assessments.
• L. Loggerwell, AFSC Fishery Interaction Team: Aleutian Islands pollock and Steller sea lion research.
• L. Fritz, NMML, Western Steller Sea Lions: Population Trends and Vital Rates.
• T. Gelatt, NMML, Diet of the Western stock Steller sea lions (Eumetopias jubatus) from 1999-2009.
• B. Fadely, NMML, Steller sea lion tracking using satellite telemetry in the western/central Aleutian Islands after the 2010 Biological Opinion.
• A. Trites, UBC, Is fishing for Atka mackerel responsible for the decline of Steller sea lions in the western and central Aleutian Islands?

Supporting Materials provided to the CIE by Presenters

• B. Tweit, Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife.
• D. Vincent-Lang, Alaska Department of Fish and Game.
• Review by Holmes of Maniscalco et al.: Evidence for high natality rates among Steller sea lions in the Gulf of Alaska, 2009.
• Review by Johnson of Maniscalco et al.: Estimating Natality Rate of Steller Sea Lions at Chiswell Island Rookery, Alaska, 2009.
• G. Merrigan: Fishing Industry Perspective of the 2010 Biological Opinion and New Available Information.
• S. Murray, Oceana.
• H. Brandon, World Wildlife Fund.
• Oceana, Ocean Conservancy, Greenpeace USA, and World Wildlife Fund.
• AFSC Steller sea lion fishery and oceanographic analysis for the 2010 BiOp, February 2010.
• Diving Behaviors and Movements of Juvenile Steller Sea Lions (Eumetopias jubatus) Captured in the Central Aleutian Islands, April 2005, Lander, et al., March 2011.

Documents Reviewed by the CIE Panel

Mandatory documents for the desk review (Chapter 1):

• National Marine Fisheries Service. November 2010. Final Biological Opinion: Authorization of Groundfish Fisheries under the Fishery Management Plans for Groundfish the Bering Sea and Aleutian Islands Management Area and the Gulf of Alaska. 472p + 224p.
• National Marine Fisheries Service. March 2008. Recovery Plan for the Steller Sea Lion:Eastern and Western Distinct Population Segments (Eumetopias jubatus). Revision. 325p.
• L. Boyd (2010) Views expressed by Professor I.L. Boyd on the Biological Opinion Groundfish Fisheries, Bering Sea and Aleutian Islands Management Area US National Marine Fisheries Service – 8 pp.
• J. M. Maniscalco, A. M. Springer, and P. Parker (2010) High Natality Rates of Endangered Steller Sea Lions in Kenai Fjords, Alaska and Perceptions of Population Status in the Gulf of Alaska – 33 pp.
• D. Calkins (2008) Fixed Gear Marine Mammal Study, North Pacific Wildlife Consulting, LLC. NOAA Grant Number: NA07NMF4390024, April 6, 2008 – 45 pp.

Mandatory documents for the panel review (Chapter 2):

• Bernard, D. R, S. J. Jefferies, G. Knapp, and A. W. Trites, 2011, An Independent Scientific Review of the Biological Opinion (2010) of the Fisheries Management Plan for the Bering Sea/Aleutian Islands Management Areas, for Alaska Department of Fish and Game (ADFG) and Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW), October 8, 2011. (PDF, 128 pages).
• M. Horning1 and J. E. Mellish. (2012). Predation on an Upper Trophic Marine Predator, the Steller Sea Lion: Evaluating High Juvenile Mortality in a Density Dependent Conceptual Framework. January 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 1 | e30173. Plosone.org. (PDF, 10 pages).
• J.N. Waite, V.N. Burkanov, and R.D. Andrews (2012). Prey competition between sympatric Steller sea lions (Eumetopias jubatus) and northern fur seals (Callorhinus ursinus) on Lovushki Island, Russia. NRC Research Press. (PDF, 18 pages).
• Demaster, D. (2011) Memorandum for Jim Balsiger regarding Results of Steller Sea Lion Surveys in Alaska, June-July 2011, December 5, 2011, Alaska Fisheries Science Center (PDF, 18 pages).
• Trites, A.W., R. Flinn, R. Joy, and B. Battaile. 2010. Was the decline of Steller sea lions in the Aleutian Islands from 2000 to 2009 related to the Atka mackerel fishery? University of British Columbia Fisheries Centre Working Paper 2010-10. 29 pp.
• Conn, P. B. (2011). An internal review of Trites et al. 2010, NOAA/NMFS/NMML, Polar Program. February 11, 2011. (PDF, 3 pages).
• Demaster D. (2011) Presentation to the North Pacific Fishery Management Council of NMFS Comments on the Bernard et al. 2011 review of the 2010 biological opinion. (PDF, 24 pages).
• T. C. Y Hui. (2011). Steller Sea Lions and Fisheries: Competition at Sea? Masters Thesis University of British Columbia, March 2011. (PDF, 114 pages).